The Unfair Struggle: Why are so many happening in British rings?

Journeymen are essential to each a rising boxer’s ring schooling and to a promoter’s steadiness sheet, however have boxing followers grow to be sick and bored with mismatches? Oliver Fennell investigates.

NAEEM ALI. Dale Arrowsmith. Taka Bembere. Elvis Dube.

Jordan Ellison. MJ Corridor. Lee Hallett. Callum Ide.

Ricky Leach. Michael Mooney. Jake Pollard. Jamie Quinn.

Darryl Sharp. Carl Turney. Lewis van Poetsch. Phil Williams.

Names – only a few names – that any common reader of Boxing Information will recognise, for they seem on these pages dozens of occasions a 12 months, generally each week.

However this isn’t a fond familiarity. In case you see these names, there’s little purpose to concentrate, for you could be virtually assured of what occurred of their fights.

In all probability, they’ll have misplaced. Most of the time, they’ll have lasted the gap, however not often successful a spherical. BN’s small corridor reporters battle to seek out something new to say when residence fighters beat journeymen by margins of 40-36 or 60-54 in virtually each contest on a card.

Pulling a current situation (July 7) of Boxing Information from my archives at random tells the story. In a single week, eight British reveals mix for 55 contests. Of those, 47 function a boxer with a dropping document, and among the stats are actually dreadful: Ten wins from 86 contests, six from 99, three in 85, two in 96… a solitary success from 25 bouts, from 33 or 49… exactly zero victories in careers stretching to 14 fights, or 18, or 36.

Most, if not all, of those loss columns could have been prolonged since. In that week, solely two of the 47 boxers with dropping information scored a win. Of the remaining 45, 39 went the gap. However that isn’t a sign of aggressive matchmaking. The “away” boxer did not win a single spherical in 33 of these distance fights (one eight-rounder, 15 sixes and 23 fours).

Nor does this mathematical dominance essentially reveal the excellence of the “residence” fighter. No, these large margins extra usually recommend the loser didn’t even try and win. As a substitute, their aim would have been to final the gap, receives a commission, go residence, and do the identical in per week or a fortnight’s time. The venue and the opponent will change, however the technique won’t.


Seamus Devlin boxed 36 occasions in his first 12 months as a professional – a British document. This was regardless of successful solely one among them – or maybe as a result of of that. He insists this isn’t for lack of attempting – a minimum of generally.

“What I’ve seen, the considering amongst most journeymen is that it’s only a job,” he says. “Me, I don’t have a look at it like that. It’s a sport to me. Typically after dropping a tough struggle, I really feel like s**t, my pleasure is harm – I wouldn’t really feel like that if I didn’t see it as a sport.

“I had a spell once I had three fights of the night time again to again [all in July]. They had been crackers. One was a draw and I ought to have gained one other of them. Nevertheless it caught up with me, having these exhausting fights and being within the health club as nicely.

“Preventing so repeatedly, it’s exhausting. So, no, I don’t all the time attempt to win. If he’s on it, firing on all cylinders, and I’m flat, possibly I’ve struggled with the burden, I may need to be an enormous unfavourable simply to get by way of [to the final bell]. However I don’t take the straightforward approach out. If I needed to try this, I’d simply take a knee.”

So, if it is a sport to Devlin, and he does attempt to win if he believes there’s an opportunity he can, is it not demoralising to have completed so solely as soon as in almost 40 contests?

“No, this sport is psychological,” says the Padiham super-middleweight. “The perfect analogy I can consider is from Band Of Brothers, when one soldier tells one other: ‘The one hope you will have is to just accept the truth that you’re already lifeless.’ In boxing, when you have no worry of dropping, you gained’t really feel that nervous vitality.

“I meet individuals they usually discover out I’m a boxer they usually ask what my document is. They don’t chuckle or scoff – they admire the very fact I step within the ring – however they don’t perceive the enterprise aspect precedes the sporting aspect of it, so they need to suppose ‘he can’t be that intelligent!’. Nevertheless it doesn’t hassle me.”

And it’s, in the end, that enterprise aspect which dictates what selections are made, even for a person who insists he’s in it for the game.

“I do know my lane and I keep in it,” says Devlin. “I used to be 33 once I turned professional, so I needed to be practical. I used to be by no means going to be a British champion, I used to be all the time going to be on the highway, so that is the best choice to make a residing for my household.

“I’m out this week and two weeks after that, and I’ve acquired an concept what I’m doing by way of to October. Once you struggle so repeatedly, self-preservation has to return high of the listing. In case you get lower, you possibly can’t field, and in case you get stopped, it’s a 28-day obligatory suspension. So, the precedence is to get out unscathed.”


With a stoppage loss mandating a four-week pay freeze, it’s the worst factor that may occur to an expert journeyman.

Truly, no – the worst that may occur is he wins. Spoil a younger fighter’s unbeaten document, or harm the fame of a ticket-seller, and promoters would possibly suppose twice earlier than using him once more.

It may not be as specific as gangsters passing envelopes underneath tables, however nonetheless there’s a monetary incentive to lose. Is that not primarily the identical as fight-fixing?

“No, no, it’s not fight-fixing in any respect,” says Robert Smith, normal secretary on the British Boxing Board of Management, “and I don’t just like the time period ‘journeymen’. They’ve been round since boxing started. Their position is to show younger boxers.

“After all, we would like everybody to have a go, however we realise some could need to go the gap to allow them to field once more subsequent week. That’s not superb, however they’ll take care of themselves. Once you see some who’re much less defensive-minded, they could have a go and get harm. So, we have now to get the steadiness proper.

“However, sure, we’re involved in regards to the one-sided nature of among the bouts. If we really feel somebody’s not attempting sufficient, we’ll convey them in with their supervisor or coach to contemplate their performances and have a look at the character of the defeats.

“And we’re doing extra testing, extra evaluation, neuropsychological exams yearly. We’re finding out alzheimer’s, dementia, CTE. We’re forward of the sport in comparison with different sports activities.

“We’re not involved with outcomes. We’re not matchmakers, we simply need to make it as secure as we probably can.”


Opinion is split amongst BN readers, though if our letters web page is any indication, extra seem like bored by the small corridor scene than enthused by it.

Ted Scott kicked off the talk on July 28 with a blunt query: “Am I the one one who finds pages of small corridor reviews, the place almost each one among them ends 40-36 in favour of the house fighter, an absolute waste of time?”.

“It’s the identical previous factor each week,” wrote Alan Cheatle per week later. “Far too usually, every struggle is an undefeated native prospect versus a serial loser… They’re tedious mismatches.”

Tom Pearson concurred: “I’ve subscribed for 5 years or so now,” he wrote on August 11. “The primary 12 months or two, I learn each line of the small corridor reviews… Then over time I realised that the overwhelming majority of it’s native prospect or native ticket vendor comfortably beating restricted opponent. And all of it acquired a bit uninteresting and repetitive.”

However Stephen Reed on August 4 known as our protection of such reveals “important studying” and “a very powerful options within the journal”.

“The 40-36 scorelines don’t all the time mirror the true nature of the bout,” he argued, “and it’s vital to learn between the traces of how exhausting the ‘away’ boxer pushed his or her opponent.”


It will be unrealistic to anticipate all contests to be 50-50 affairs, and small corridor reveals are constrained by tight budgets, so journeymen are essential to each a rising boxer’s ring schooling and to a promoter’s steadiness sheet. They usually save contests and even whole reveals by stepping in at quick discover when fights fall by way of. All of us respect journeymen and their position, it’s simply we’d like issues to be a bit much less predictable generally, whether or not we’re a fan, a journalist – and even the “residence” fighter.

“I’ve been in with eight journeymen,” says 11-1-1 Welsh middleweight champion Gerome Warburton, recent off a 40-36 win over Jordan Grannum (6-99-4), “and solely two of them gave me an honest struggle. All of the others did was survive like wounded animals. I do suppose the usual of some has been very poor. They’ve simply been punchbags.

“I attempt to make it entertaining. It’s exhausting to inform your followers you’re boxing somebody with 100 losses. On the finish of the day, you need to entertain the followers, however a few of my fights have been poor [to watch].

“Typically, my opponents are paid greater than me. Fifteen or sixteen hundred [pounds], whereas I’m solely getting a grand, and I’m anticipated to carry again as a result of they’re preventing subsequent week? I don’t maintain again for anyone. I’m right here to do a job – you do yours. Don’t do it half-hearted!”

Warburton, from Colwyn Bay, believes it’s this mentality of treating dropping fights as companies rendered, usually with advance bookings, that leads some boxers to prioritise survival over victory.

“You look a few of these guys up on BoxRec they usually’ve acquired three or 4 fights booked after yours,” he says. “I don’t agree with this, preventing each week. They’re simply trying previous you to the subsequent payday.

“I do respect journeymen, although. With out them, there can be no boxing, as a result of most good boxers don’t need to struggle one another. And you continue to should take these fights severely, as a result of in boxing, one punch can change the whole lot.”


Certainly it may well. Whereas we, and a few readers, are complaining about repetitiveness and predictability, you actually by no means can take something with no consideration on this sport.

A document that reads, for instance, 2-23, tells you two issues – one, {that a} win is extremely unlikely, however two, that it can occur.

I used to be at a present in Manchester in August 2021 when such lightning struck. It was a nine-bout providing compiled solely of residence fighter vs journeyman fare. I used to be reporting for a newspaper, in any other case to be completely sincere I wouldn’t have been there, and it was tough to keep up my focus ranges and curiosity even when being paid to take action. One of many matches seemed as predictable because the others: a ticket-selling native in a four-rounder in opposition to a serial loser.

However on that night time, Irlam light-heavyweight Ryan Hibbert (1-12) went after the house fighter – well-supported Mancunian debutant Anthony Phythian – with seen intent, rocked him dramatically halfway by way of the primary spherical, after which went for the end, flattening Phythian on the 2-11 mark.

Why was this so totally different?

“I simply knew immediately I had his quantity,” says Hibbert.

“I knew him from the white collar days [both Hibbert and Phythian were unlicensed boxers prior to turning pro]. We had been imagined to struggle a couple of occasions, however by no means did, so when it occurred, I simply felt supremely assured, so I give it him.”

Does Hibbert often attempt to win?

“I decide and select which fights to go for it,” he says. “Typically I get matched fairly exhausting and it’s just about a aware resolution to simply go the gap. I do know within the first minute if I can’t win, so I exploit my expertise, my ring savvy, ducking and diving, tie them up, dance round.”

The Phythian win got here at a predictable price, although. “I had my subsequent struggle cancelled due to that,” says Hibbert. “Phrase acquired spherical, particularly the best way I’d completed him.

“I’ve identified a couple of lads have three of 4 fights cancelled [after winning]. The promoters don’t need exhausting fights for his or her boxers.”


David McAllister, who promotes small corridor reveals within the north of Scotland, says such occasions don’t have a tendency to draw discerning boxing followers; fairly, many of the crowd is comprised of family and friends of the house fighter.

“It’s largely individuals supporting their buddies,” he says. “They need an evening out, a couple of beers, and to cheer on their mate. They don’t know if an opponent’s acquired 100 losses.”

Even so, McAllister understands they nonetheless need to be entertained, and so chooses his journeymen appropriately.

“We attempt to get those who comes and check out, not simply run away and decide up their wages,” he says. “I’m in search of ones who don’t usually get stopped, who’re sturdy, who’re possibly a weight above my child, who can train my child various things and might take some rounds off them.

“It’s no good when he’s simply standing there not throwing punches. That’s no good to anybody, you’re not studying something. I would like my child to know if he leaves his guard open, he’s going to get a proper hand in his face.”

Some journeymen present real exams and studying experiences. Others are extra content material to be paid-for record-padders. McAllister agrees the latter have grow to be extra frequent, and says the explanation for that is two-fold – however each are associated to cash.

“The position of the journeyman isn’t what it was once,” he says. “Boxers didn’t use to begin out as journeymen. They’d get a couple of wins but when, after a couple of losses, their ticket gross sales went down, they noticed they may earn more money because the away fighter – however they’d nonetheless come and have an actual struggle. These days, boxers see how journeymen can usually earn more money than prospects, by boxing three or 4 occasions a month, and it’s their aim proper from the beginning.

“Promoters should take a whole lot of the blame, to be honest, by simply specializing in ticket gross sales. Younger youngsters come to them and say ‘I can promote 300-400 tickets’, however they’ll’t field, in order that they’re getting protected due to the tickets they promote.

“I’ve been at [other promoters’] reveals and I’ve seen a journeyman sitting in his nook, laughing, telling his cornerman ‘If I hit this child, he’s going to fold’. I’ve seen a journeyman holding a child up together with his left arm. I used to be at one struggle that was simply embarrassing; the child was so nervous he wasn’t throwing punches, and the journeyman wasn’t throwing punches both as a result of he didn’t need to win. Once they’re attempting [i]to not[i] win, it simply makes a mockery of the game.

“They [the promoters] don’t need to take an opportunity. However a defeat isn’t the be all and finish all.”

Nicely, that relies upon which nook you’re in. For some, a defeat – or, extra particularly, permitting your self to be defeated – is what’s value preventing for many of all.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *